Home » ExchangeEveryDay » Academic versus Intellectual Learning



ExchangeEveryDay Past Issues


<< Previous Issue | View Past Issues | | Next Issue >> ExchangeEveryDay
Academic versus Intellectual Learning
March 24, 2008
When a child walks into a room, your child or anyone else's child, do your eyes light up? That’s what they are looking for.
-Toni Morrison
The 30th Anniversary issue of Exchange (March 2008; www.ChildCareExchange.com) included a very special Beginnings Workshop section on "School Readiness" with articles by Nancy Carlsson-Paige, David Elkind, Lilian Katz, and Marjorie Kostelnik. In this section, Lilian Katz, who is the lead-off speaker at the Working Forum for Teacher Educators observed...

"Many of those involved in policy decision-making assume that the early childhood curriculum consists largely either of spontaneous play or formal academic instruction. It is, however, important to keep in mind that these are not the only two options for the preschool curriculum. Furthermore, that while both play and instruction can have a place in the curriculum, both positions overlook the importance of children’s intellectual development. To highlight the contrasts, academic goals are those concerned with acquiring small discrete bits of disembedded information, usually related to pre-literacy skills, and practiced in drills, worksheets, and other kinds of exercises designed to prepare them for later literacy and numeracy learning. The items learned and practiced require correct answers, rely heavily on memorization, and consist largely of giving the teacher the correct answers that the children know she wants. These bits of information are essential components of reading and other academic competencies. The issue here is not whether academic skills matter; rather it is when they matter. Intellectual goals and their related activities, on the other hand, address the life of the mind in its fullest sense, including a range of aesthetic and moral sensibilities. The formal definition of the concept of intellectual emphasizes reasoning, hypothesizing, predicting, the development and analysis of ideas, and the quest for understanding.

"With the intellectual dispositions in mind, an appropriate curriculum in the early years is one that encourages and motivates children to seek mastery of basic academic skills (e.g., beginning writing skills), in the service of their intellectual pursuits. In this way, the children should be able to sense the purposefulness of the activities and their efforts to find things out. While intellectual dispositions may be weakened or even damaged by excessive and premature formal instruction, they are also not likely to be strengthened by many of the trivial, if not banal (e.g., refrigerator art?), activities frequently offered in early childhood settings.

"I suggest that when young children engage in projects in which they conduct investigations of significant objects and events around them and for which they have developed the research questions to find out things like how things work, what things are made of, what people around them do to contribute to their well-being, and so forth, their minds are fully engaged. Furthermore, the usefulness and importance of being able to read, write, measure, and count gradually becomes self-evident."




"School Readiness" and all other 85 Beginnings Workshop sets are now on sale for only $5 each. Beginnings Workshops address the following curriculum areas:
  • Child Development
  • Program Development
  • Professional Development
  • Language and Literacy
  • Curriculum Issues
  • Environments
  • Parents

ExchangeEveryDay

Delivered five days a week containing news, success stories, solutions, trend reports, and much more.

What is ExchangeEveryDay?

ExchangeEveryDay is the official electronic newsletter for Exchange Press. It is delivered five days a week containing news stories, success stories, solutions, trend reports, and much more.

Online degrees in early childhood education
Completely online from a regionally accredited institution - the University of Cincinnati!


Comments (4)

Displaying All 4 Comments
Sharon Young · May 26, 2008
Houston, Texas, United States


After 20 years in preschool classrooms, I asked to be let out of the box to become an Outdoor Coordinator, where children and adults have more spontaneous experiences. The joy of teaching had been reduced as I was expected to facilitate an assembly line of arts and crafts, so every child could have refrigerator art as proof of their fun day, while learning, of course. I came to think of it as a daily birthday party with home made party favors.
By contrast my professional early childhood training prepared me to enter a child's play to have a relationship through conversations. While spontaneity reflects experience as a teacher, our posted curriculum schedules should include teacher interaction time to illustrate the value of spontaneous interaction.

Luz Maldonado · March 26, 2008
Wilmington, Delaware, United States


The article speaks to refelctions I have in teaching today. I do believe the article's position on intellectual development. That children need to learn to investigate and acquire the process of learning along with the basic skills drill.

Sometimes that is difficult to do when the demand to have all students at the same literacy levels is so great.
How are you fellow teachers balancing the need for intellectual development with academic achievement?

M K- Elder · March 24, 2008
high quality resources
Deer Park, New York, United States


Loved the article, it was refreshing to read. Educators need to facilitate and create an environment where children will be able to deduct their own hypothesis.
Facilitators or teachers should not always expect one answer when children are really learning, it's the process not the outcome!
M. K- Elder
www.myhqr.com

Sunny Davidson · March 24, 2008
Color Outside The Lines
Tyler, TX, United States


What a lovely, intellectual statement about the way children conceive knowledge.

How contrary to the "Alphabet song".

Thank you.

Sunny Davidson



Post a Comment

Have an account? to submit your comment.


required

Your e-mail address will not be visible to other website visitors.
required
required
required

Check the box below, to help verify that you are not a bot. Doing so helps prevent automated programs from abusing this form.



Disclaimer: Exchange reserves the right to remove any comments at its discretion or reprint posted comments in other Exchange materials.