Home » ExchangeEveryDay » The Politics of Child Care



ExchangeEveryDay Past Issues


<< Previous Issue | View Past Issues | | Next Issue >> ExchangeEveryDay
The Politics of Child Care
June 3, 2009
The ultimate gift we can give the world is to grow our tiny humans into adult humans who are independent thinkers…Our world needs more adults who question and challenge and hold the powerful accountable.
-L.R. Knost
The response to last Friday's ExchangeEveryDay ("Yes We Can!"), highlighted the complexity of politics in the early childhood arena. To begin with, when it comes to national politics, our field is as divided as the country itself. In Exchange Insta Polls on the last three U.S. presidential elections, the combined results have been relatively evenly divided between the Republican and Democratic candidates.

When you take a closer look at our profession, there are no obvious dividing lines. Some respondents on Friday seemed to suggest that those in the for-profit sector are conservatives and those in the non-profit sector are liberals. However, while there may be a slight bias along these lines, we have encountered many strong liberals operating for-profit child care companies and many extremely conservative individuals operating non-profit centers. In the non-profit sector alone, people working in religious-affiliated, Head Start, military, Montessori, United Way, government operated, and community programs have widely diverse political perspectives.

This great diversity makes for the richness of our profession, but it also explains why our field has been so unsuccessful in uniting behind any specific funding and regulatory initiatives.

Given the complex politics of child care, it would be counterproductive for Exchange to try to promote any one political point of view. In fact, we challenge those who think we have a bias to read the 1,860 past issues of ExchangeEveryDay on display on our web site, or the 2,014 past articles from Exchange magazine in our online articles database. We would be surprised if anyone could attribute a political bias to more than 5 or 6 of these 3,874 articles.

But that does not mean we shy away from sharing perspectives of others. And, when we share views from people with strong perspectives, we expect to continue to stir up some healthy discussions. We welcome everyone's perspectives.



For 30 years Exchange has been chronicling the history of and trends in the early childhood profession. Now we have compiled 150 Exchange reports on early childhood trends and history into a single CD Book. Your purchase of Early Childhood Trend Report CD Book includes periodic FREE electronic updates to help ensure you're always on top of the latest developments in this ever-changing environment.

ExchangeEveryDay

Delivered five days a week containing news, success stories, solutions, trend reports, and much more.

What is ExchangeEveryDay?

ExchangeEveryDay is the official electronic newsletter for Exchange Press. It is delivered five days a week containing news stories, success stories, solutions, trend reports, and much more.

PreschoolFirst
  • Online play-based assessment & curriculum for Infant/toddlers
  • Variety — choose from 3,200 activities
  • 300+ family activities
  • Meaningful progress reports
  • Aligned to all state early learning standards
  • Easy to use with accountability
  • FREE TRIAL



Comments (4)

Displaying All 4 Comments
Paula · June 03, 2009
Marian Children\'s Center
Santa Maria, CA, United States


I applaud today's article on the "Politics of Child Care". I agree that there are diverse opinions regarding who is responsible for the care of children in our great country. In my opinion, Being liberal or conservative does not change the quality of care a child receives. Whether we continue to provide the very best care possible in the variety of ways we currently provide it, or, the government establishes a nationwide program, what will make the difference in the care that children receive is the commitment the nation's teacher's have to excellence in their profession, and the belief that their professionalism, advocacy, education and training make a difference in the lives of young children. The delivery system is worth nothing without teachers who strive for quality every day. Raising early childhood teacher's salaries to that of elementary teachers won't be an indicator of or guarantee quality either. Building an educated, professional workforce, however, may just lead to better salaries for those of us who work with young children!

Roberta Bernhard · June 03, 2009
Newark Preschool Council
Montclair, NJ, NJ, United States


It's good

Kathy Graham · June 03, 2009
Stirling, ON, Canada


You have "hit the issue on the head" with your statement: "This great diversity makes for the richness of our profession, but it also explains why our field has been so unsuccessful in uniting behind any specific funding and regulatory initiatives."

In the 33 years that I tirelessly advocated for families and childcare in Canada our richness is what divides us. Instead of, 'as educators and teachers acting as role models to demonstrate tolerance, consensus building, collaboration and team work' what we have given to the children is 'intolerance, attacks and divisiveness - anything but team work'.

We teach and expect children to 'act an acceptable way' yet we fail them miserably as role models, and I would say to the delight of politicians who don't have to respond to our needs because we are too busy fighting among ourselves while they are listening to cohesive industries vying for the funding.

As a woman I have always found it incomprehensible that in a female dominated profession we attack each other as to who is better instead of looking at the merits and contributions of all sectors and bring about programs that meet the needs of all families in all situations whether they are families who need and want childcare or whether they are a family who desires to stay at home with their young children.

Kudos to the ever thought provoking team at Exchange and WoFo who inspire us and encourage us to be our very best no matter where we are or who we are!

Rod · June 03, 2009
Birmingham, AL, United States


From my experience there are only a very few people whether religious, political or cultural who recognize their own biases. Most are either blind or ignorant of them. Some who are aware of their own biases are afraid to admit them. If there is one person who thinks your perspective is flawed or mistaken, and you don't understand why they think that, then you are biased. Bias is a mental preference that results in our preferring something over another, sometimes with justification (at least to one's self) and sometimes without.

Human beings cannot help but presenting their own perspective and position in a way that best illustrates it. Normally that means putting opposing positions and perspectives in the worst possible light. In addition biases are often revealed in what is not said! For example, the editors of news organizations can reveal their bias by what they do not report. That choice is based on what they feel is newsworthy and their choices are based in their biases.

There is no real solution to this other than the acknowledgement of our bias. For example, the conservative should go ahead and admit they are conservative, the moderate admit that they are moderates, and liberals admit that they are liberals.

There are really few dead center moderates. It is easy to determine. You are a moderate if you find yourself disagree with the liberal and conservative positions 50% of the time or if you can honesty see each positions point and cannot decide which you want to align with.

We are all biased and that's ok. We still can get along together if we are willing to talk and be respectful (an not villainize, whether its Bush or Obama).



Post a Comment

Have an account? to submit your comment.


required

Your e-mail address will not be visible to other website visitors.
required
required
required

Check the box below, to help verify that you are not a bot. Doing so helps prevent automated programs from abusing this form.



Disclaimer: Exchange reserves the right to remove any comments at its discretion or reprint posted comments in other Exchange materials.