ExchangeEveryDay Past Issues
<< Previous Issue
|
Browse by Title | |
Next Issue >>
June 4, 2012
Some people walk in the rain, others just get wet.
-Roger Miller
"One of the essential attributes of a good teacher — from preschool through graduate school — is the disposition to respect learners," observes Lilian Katz in her book sold by Exchange, Intellectual Emergencies: Some Reflections on Mothering and Teaching. She explains...
"I suggest that to respect the learner means, among other things, attributing to the learner positive qualities, intentions, and expectations, even when the available evidence may cast doubts on the learner's possession of these attributes. A respectful relationship between the teacher and the learner is marked also by treating learners with dignity, listening closely and attentively to what the learners say, as well as looking for what they seem reluctant to say. Respect also includes treating the learners as sensible persons, even though that assumption sometimes requires a stretch of the teacher's imagination. When it comes to young children this element of respect implies that we should resist the temptation to talk to young children in silly sweet voices, heaping empty praise on them, and giving them certificates indicating that smiling bear believes they are special. This disrespectful strategy makes a mockery of teaching. After all, teaching is about helping learners to make better, deeper, and fuller sense of their experience and to derive deep satisfaction from the processes of doing so. Education, after all, is not about amusement, excitement, or entertainment."
Save 25% when you purchase the following titles on learning situations, this week only!
Sale ends 06/08/2012. The Learning Moments CDs can be used on PC or Mac platform.
ExchangeEveryDay
Delivered five days a week containing news, success stories, solutions, trend reports, and much more.
Unsubscribe
United States
06/05/2012 11:35 am
I hope there is the possibility of excitement in learning - when the learning makes a connection between what they already know and what they are discovering and learning - there is excitement!
United States
06/05/2012 11:33 am
I hope learning does include the possibility for excitement - when a learner makes a connection between what they know and what they have discovered and are learning, there is excitement!
United States
06/04/2012 05:52 am
Another great bit of wisdom from Lilian Katz. However, isn't there excitement in learning? In discovery? In searching and researching?
Yorktown, VA, United States
06/04/2012 05:22 am
And I would suggest that we often anthropomorphize inanimate objects and animals, too. That's not to say young children are not human. Rather, it is to say that the use of high pitch intonation is developmentally appropriate with small children. Linguistics studies have consistently shown that infants and toddlers are particularly attentive to, responsive to, and relaxed when a high pitch tone is used by adults. Young children do not consider "respect," as the concept is too abstract for their level of brain development. Rather, young children consider (respond) to that which is relatable...at their level. As children get older, of course one should adjust their manner of speech to a more mature level, always at the developmental level of the child. It is inappropriate to interact with children as if they are adults. The best teachers communicate with children's at the child's developmental capacity for cognition.
Bronx, NY, United States
06/04/2012 04:17 am
When it comes to young children this element of respect implies that we should resist the temptation to talk to young children in silly sweet voices, heaping empty praise on them, and giving them certificates indicating that smiling bear believes they are special. This disrespectful strategy makes a mockery of teaching.
EXCELLENT!!! I work with Group/Family, and Teachers in NYC. Thus far I see that little intrique gifts are given for things to me that make not sense. If this is praise, then what will they give for a jobe well done?
Sharon