Home » ExchangeEveryDay » The Plague of ADHD



ExchangeEveryDay Past Issues


<< Previous Issue | View Past Issues | | Next Issue >> ExchangeEveryDay
The Plague of ADHD
January 18, 2011
Once I spoke the language of the flowers. . . . How did it go? How did it go?
-Excerpt from "Forgotten Language" by Shel Silverstein, 1930-1999

I have resisted sending ExchangeEveryDay readers to YouTube since you all get more links to YouTube than you can deal with about cats that swim and teenagers doing weird things on skateboards. However, when Kirsten Haugen sent in a presentation by Sir Ken Robinson, world-renowned education and creativity expert, with his speech matched up with a clever graphics presentation, we were wowed. We decided you needed to see it. Here are some excerpts from his speech, "Changing Education Paradigms", where he talks about ADHD; but this is taken out of context and we encourage you to listen to the entire speech:

"Don't mistake me, I don't mean to say that there's no such thing as Attention Deficit Disorder. I'm not qualified to say if there is such a thing. I know that a great majority of psychologists and pediatricians think there is such a thing. But it's still a matter of debate. What I do know for a fact is that it's not an epidemic. These kids are being medicated as routinely as we had our tonsils taken out... And on the same whimsical basis and for the same reason: medical fashion.

"Our children are living in the most intensive, stimulating period in the history of the earth. They're being besieged with information and calls for their attention from every platform: computers, from iPhones, from advertising hoardings from hundreds of television channels, and we are penalizing them for being distracted.

"From what? Boring stuff, at school for the most part. It seems to me that it's not a coincidence totally that the incidence of ADHD has risen in parallel with the growth of standardized testing. Now, these kids are being given Ritalin and Adderall and all manner of things, often quite dangerous drugs, to get them focused and to calm them down...

"An anesthetic is when you shut your senses off and deaden yourself to what is happening. And a lot of these drugs are that. We are getting our children through education by anesthetizing them. And I think we should be doing exactly the opposite. We shouldn't be putting them asleep; we should be waking them up to what they have inside of themselves...

"I believe we have a system of education that is modeled in the image of industrialism... Schools are still organized in factory lines: ringing bells, separate facilities, specialized into separate subjects. We still educate children by batches. We put them through the system by age group.

"Why do we do that? Why is there this assumption that the most important thing kids have in common is how old they are? It's like the most important thing about them is the date of manufacture. Well, I know kids that are better than other kids of the same age in different disciplines. Or different times of the day. Or better in smaller rather than larger groups. Or sometimes they want to be on their own.

"If you are interested in the model of learning, you don't start from this production-line mentality. It is essentially about conformity and increasingly it is about that growth of standardized testing and standardized curricula... I believe we've got to go in the opposite direction. That's what I mean about changing the paradigm."





Teaching Four-Year-Olds:
A Personal Journey

Use coupon code FOUR
to save 20% on Teaching Four-Year-Olds

What does every young child need to be a well-adjusted, happy person? From Carol Hillman's years of experience and wisdom comes the answer: Help each child discover a world where play, creative freedom, self trust, and personal responsibility open the child's mind and heart to the excitement of learning and the enjoyment of sharing it with others.

Enter coupon code "FOUR" when at checkout.

Offer valid through June 9, 2020 at 11:59 pm Pacific Time.
May not be combined with any other offer.

ExchangeEveryDay

Delivered five days a week containing news, success stories, solutions, trend reports, and much more.

What is ExchangeEveryDay?

ExchangeEveryDay is the official electronic newsletter for Exchange Press. It is delivered five days a week containing news stories, success stories, solutions, trend reports, and much more.


Join 25,000 other child care centers just like yours that now operate more efficiently than ever before using our software & check-in solutions.

Procare Software
Introducing Scholastic Big Day for PreK a new, comprehensive program that embraces children’s natural curiosity and prepares children for success in school and life! Based on the most current research, Big Day for PreK provides everything teachers need to create a purposeful and fun learning environment.



Comments (14)

Displaying 5 of 14 Comments   [ View all ]
Dale Wares · January 25, 2011
Oklahoma Department of Human Services
Oklahoma City, OK, United States


I recently interviewed my 77 year old cousin in an attempt to preserve family history in danger of being lost. He attended a one room school where first through eighth grades were taught by one teacher. He talked about the benefit of hearing lessons presented to the older students and thought the multiage classroom was valuable for learning. I would add that it probably also promoted self discipline because students had to work independently when other age groups were engage with the teacher.

Debbie · January 20, 2011
NM, United States


I think people (teachers, doctors, etc...) need to look at the whole child in each situation. The current education system doesn't fit many children - possibly a strong reason that homeschooling is gaining momentum. We homeschool, try to keep a slower pace, don't watch TV, and limit any screen time for our children. Yet, our 6 year old has symptoms of ADHD. He may or may not actually have ADHD - the symptoms overlap with other possible issues. We will NOT medicate him! We have actually found out that he needs glasses and vision therapy (again, the symptoms overlap). Since we homeschool, we can provide the best environment for him without drugs! And our learning is ACTIVE - we don't sit with paper and pencil all day!
Also, if the government could see the benefits to the structure and philosophy of the Waldorf schools, our children would have a better chance for success in their world!

Patricia Bozell · January 20, 2011
Washington,DC, DC, United States


Fantastic article! The assumption that children need to be medicated for any obscure behavioral momentum is absurd. Our society has created a fast living world holding back creativity. This results in utter confusion. We need to approach each child as one. One alone and just as special. Allow this individual's creativity flourish and live. Live without the bonds of medication and their side effects. Thank you for such an impressive, well thought article. Very refreshing.

Suse King · January 19, 2011
Australia


In an article published in QWeekend on January 15, 2011 there is an indepth interview and story about "The Remarkable Mr. Rush". ' Rush describes his boyhood self as the "skinny little boy by the water's edge", a late bloomer in love with the planets.....When his friends were in love with West Indian cricketers he was in love with Copernicus and Tycho Brahe.......
"I was a very late player. I used to play under the house with friends five years my junior, really. A sense of play existed well into my mid years of high school. And then I got caught up in the school drama club and there was another outlet of play on a different level."


Imagine what would have happened to Geoffrey Rush if he had been forced to do other than "play". We might now not have the wonderful actor that he has turned out to be. What if someone had told him that he should not associate with younger children.....

We should take from this article that every child in an individual, with strengths and possiblities beyond comprehension. Educators only have to encourage children to be themselves.

Isamari Rivera · January 18, 2011
Toa Alta, PR, Puerto Rico


Finally I heard something that it is meaningful and make sense. However, I am convinced that there are real ADD & ADHD "patients" who really need other alternatives such as drugs. But most of the "patients", in this case children are misdiagnose and treated for being responsive to all the information sent to them at the same time. So, the question is: How are we going to address the Change?
Our system trends to stay the same as 30 years ago. How come? We want humankind stay the same, but in the contrary we continiuosly keep evolving and developing. Which will be your role in the line of CHANGE?
Think!



Post a Comment

Have an account? to submit your comment.


required

Your e-mail address will not be visible to other website visitors.
required
required
required

Check the box below, to help verify that you are not a bot. Doing so helps prevent automated programs from abusing this form.



Disclaimer: Exchange reserves the right to remove any comments at its discretion or reprint posted comments in other Exchange materials.